Season 10 - Why Get Rid Of So Many Characters At Once?

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
People generally think of there being 3 important characters they lost after season 10:

Pam
Donna
Mandy

There was a 4th - Ewing Oil. You could say that Ewing Oil and Southfork were so important to Dallas that you could consider them both characters. Dallas without Ewing Oil just wasn't the same, just as Dallas without Southfork wouldn't have been the same either.

Why would they schedule things so that they lost Pam, Donna, Mandy and Ewing Oil all at the same time? It seems self destructive to me.
 

Grant Jennings

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
I had stopped watching by that point but I do know that both Victoria Principal and Susan Howard had decided on their own to leave the series, they even mentioned it at one of the awards shows that season (you can find the video on Youtube). Principal had reportedly grown tired of the role of Pam and thought the writers had stopped developing the character. Howard already had a bad taste in her mouth over the decision to eliminate her storyline from the dream season and was frustrated with her diminished role after that. I don't know if Deborah Shelton quit or was fired.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Victoria wanted financial parity with Duffy and would only sign for one more year; Lorimar wanted two years, and agreed to a big raise but not as much as she was asking ("her demands were very high," said and executive... It was likely her way of quitting , since she probably knew they wouldn't concede. Reportedly, a year later they agreed to her terms and floated the offer through Larry during a dinner, but VP wasn't interested in returning.

Susan Howard wanted to stay, but Katzman was apparently ticked off about her public criticism of use of The Dream scenario. Also, Lorimar had just been bought out by Telepictures in 1986, and supporting actors were being cut left and right on their shows.

Mandy's storyline was probably seen as having wrapped up.

B&W1987DallasCastPhoto_2web.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Dr. Ellby's hair

Telly Talk Member
Imdb.com claims that Patrick Duffy after his 1986 return "Earned $75,000 per episode...(1986-91)"
and Victoria Principal "$35,000 per week (season 10)"
Does anyone know how much money other members of the core cast were getting per episode around 1987?
 

Toni

Maximum Member

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I had stopped watching by that point but I do know that both Victoria Principal and Susan Howard had decided on their own to leave the series, they even mentioned it at one of the awards shows that season (you can find the video on Youtube). Principal had reportedly grown tired of the role of Pam and thought the writers had stopped developing the character. Howard already had a bad taste in her mouth over the decision to eliminate her storyline from the dream season and was frustrated with her diminished role after that. I don't know if Deborah Shelton quit or was fired.

Back in 1987 I heard a different explanation for why VP left, which came directly from Larry Hagman, since it's from an interview he did for one of the shows which reported entertainment news. Probably it was Entertainment Tonight. It's very possible that the real reason for VP leaving is somewhere in between the reasons you gave and the following explanation.

The explanation was that she wanted to become a movie star and wanted to start working on that goal before she started losing her good looks. I don't know how it is now, but back in the 80s, if a woman hadn't made it in movies by around age 40, she probably never would because there were few significant roles for older women.

So, her decision to leave in 1987 probably had about as much to do with her being tired of playing Pam as Patrick Duffy's decision to leave in 1985 had to do with him being tired of playing Bobby - they must have had days at work where their jobs seemed repetitive because almost everyone has days like that - but Victoria Principal's decision was primarily based upon having to go after her dream while she was still young enough to have a reasonable shot at succeeding.

Larry Hagman said he completely understood her decision to leave because she was talented and so good looking that she had a legitimate shot at becoming a movie star but only if she didn't wait any longer to go after it. He added that men had a lot more opportunities after a certain age than women did in the movie business.

VP got a starring role in a made for TV movie that same year, so she did go after that goal. She went on to make several made for TV movies but that's as far as she got - only made for TV movies.

I saw one of her movies - "Mistress." I remember thinking it was alright but that's about all I remember; it was so long ago.

As for Susan Howard you say she was upset that they eliminated her storyline from the dream season. Well, they did that to everyone - not just her. She must have realized that so why would she be so upset over it? Besides, Donna still got to have a baby. In the dream season she tried to have a baby and it turned out badly (Downs Syndrome) so they were going to adopt a kid. In the next season Donna got pregnant and had a baby so they kept that element of the story. The big difference of course os that Donna left Ray in the next season. That was the beginning of the end for her character because since she was divorcing Ray she wouldn't be part of the Ewing family anymore and by moving to Washington DC she isolated herself from everything that was going on in Dallas. They didn;t have to have her move to DC though. They could have had her get into state politics instead of national politics. They also could have had her stay with Ray. These were things that were easily avoidable if she'd wanted to stay. At the push of a pen, Donna and Ray could have reconciled and ended up raising their daughter together.

I´m sure that @Sarah would disagree... :spinning::spinning::spinning::spinning::spinning:

I'm sure she would. It's a testament to Debby Shelton's acting ability that she gets such strong reactions from people whether they're like me and think JR should have married Mandy and not Cally, or whether they're like Sarah and despise Mandy. There is no in between.. Mandy is a very polarizing character - people usually either love her or hate her.
 
Last edited:
Susan Howard wanted to stay, but Katzman was apparently ticked off about her public criticism of use of The Dream scenario.

At some point I recall reading that there was some friction between Susan and the powers that be on the series because she'd been unhappy with what she perceived as a pro-choice storyline for Donna. I'm not clear on how - or even if - that played out (did Ray and Donna discuss abortion in Season Eight? Or could the storyline have been changed to the tasteless "gored by a bull" scenario to steer round it?). But if it's true, the complaint would have been another strike against Howard.


As for Susan Howard you say she was upset that they eliminated her storyline from the dream season. Well, they did that to everyone - not just her. She must have realized that so why would she be so upset over it?

I can understand why she'd be proud of her work. Say what you will about some of her "very special episode" storylines of Season Eight, but I was very impressed to see Howard throwing herself into details like using sign language and could tell she felt what was happening onscreen was valid. The dream resolution was an insult to viewers and to those who were involved in the creation of Season Eight, and if Howard chose not to by toe the party line when discussing it then I admire her for it.


The big difference of course os that Donna left Ray in the next season. That was the beginning of the end for her character because since she was divorcing Ray she wouldn't be part of the Ewing family anymore and by moving to Washington DC she isolated herself from everything that was going on in Dallas.

The move to Washington being written in was rather telling. Sue Ellen had previously divorced JR. Pam had divorced Bobby. But they were still written as central characters. Donna was sidelined. And instead they paired Ray with Jenna.


They didn;t have to have her move to DC though. They could have had her get into state politics instead of national politics. They also could have had her stay with Ray. These were things that were easily avoidable if she'd wanted to stay.

Or if they'd wanted her to.


There is no in between.. Mandy is a very polarizing character - people usually either love her or hate her.

I'm lukewarm where Mandy is concerned. She was fine in filling the role previously occupied by Afton and had decent chemistry with some of the characters, but she was never anything more than a secondary character to me. And I'm fairly sure she was cast for points other than her acting ability.
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
I'm sure she would. It's a testament to Debby Shelton's acting ability that she gets such strong reactions from people whether they're like me and think JR should have married Mandy and not Cally, or whether they're like Sarah and despise Mandy. There is no in between.. Mandy is a very polarizing character - people usually either love her or hate her.

Acting ability??! Em no. Storylines? Yes.

But I guess she was capable of portraying a truly horrid person or ‘manipulative homewrecker’ (Deborah Shelton’s own words!). Unfortunately beyond that, her acting isn’t very strong. It’s the storylines that provoke the strong reaction from me.

I certainly don’t think JR should have married her and really wish people would base their opinion on her on something more than her alleged good looks (which paled in comparison to her ugly personality!). It would never have lasted. Long term she couldn’t have handled JR.

It’s interesting what you say about love and hate though Kenny. I would pretty much bet my years salary that if she had cheated with Bobby that she she’d fall much more into the hatred category. I wonder how people would feel about her had she worked her cruel schemes or nasty tongue on Pam....?

Just as Jenna and April are hated by many - even though neither of them actually cheated with Bobby while he was married.....always strikes me as odd, that way of thinking!

The only importance that Mandy had was that her actions made Sue Ellen take control of her life and stop drinking. There was zero use for her after that.

‘Disposable peace of facial tissue’. That’s being polite Sue Ellen my love.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
It’s interesting what you say about love and hate though Kenny. I would pretty much bet my years salary that if she had cheated with Bobby that she she’d fall much more into the hatred category. I wonder how people would feel about her had she worked her cruel schemes or nasty tongue on Pam....?

Those are some interesting scenarios. I wonder how I would have felt about her had she come in between Pam and Bobby? I guess it would depend on the details such as would Bobby have pursued her relentlessly or would Mandy have been chasing after Bobby.

If JR and Sue Ellen had had a happy marriage I would have certainly felt differently regarding Mandy.. I honestly thought that by that time JR and Sue Ellen were making each other miserable so I didn't see there being much of a marriage to break up. Sue Ellen was in love with Dusty while JR was seeing Mandy.

I like that Mandy genuinely loved JR; most of the women JR had affairs with were mostly just interested in sleeping with JR - women like Marilee Stone (a complete nymphomaniac which I find very unappealing), Angelica Nero, Serena (obviously since she was a call girl), and the woman JR slept with in Austin during the storyline about Cliff's Blue Ribbon committee deciding which oil tanker was at fault for the colission.

I've never asked you this but I'm curious: What is your opinion of Dusty? I'm guessing that you didn't like that he was getting in the way of Sue Elle and JR but I'd like to see what you have to say about Dusty and also what you think about Sue Ellen's affair with Dusty.

Just as Jenna and April are hated by many - even though neither of them actually cheated with Bobby while he was married.....always strikes me as odd, that way of thinking!

Then I take it you like, or at least don't dislike Jenna and April. Good, because I like both Jenna and April, especially April.
 
Last edited:

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
I'd really not place Mandy among "important" characters to be fair. She was a recurring character whose storyline just ended.

Honestly, I was surprised to see that she has a credit for 63 episodes as it doesn't feel that long to me - but maybe that comes down to me tending not to rewatch the Dream Season...

Mandy's storyline was probably seen as having wrapped up.

Wasn't Mandy like Jamie in the sense that she ended up being brought back for season 10 because of the dream scenario? I seem to remember feeling like her storyline wrapped in season nine.
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
Acting ability??! Em no. Storylines? Yes.

But I guess she was capable of portraying a truly horrid person or ‘manipulative homewrecker’ (Deborah Shelton’s own words!). Unfortunately beyond that, her acting isn’t very strong. It’s the storylines that provoke the strong reaction from me.

I certainly don’t think JR should have married her and really wish people would base their opinion on her on something more than her alleged good looks (which paled in comparison to her ugly personality!). It would never have lasted. Long term she couldn’t have handled JR.

It’s interesting what you say about love and hate though Kenny. I would pretty much bet my years salary that if she had cheated with Bobby that she she’d fall much more into the hatred category. I wonder how people would feel about her had she worked her cruel schemes or nasty tongue on Pam....?

Just as Jenna and April are hated by many - even though neither of them actually cheated with Bobby while he was married.....always strikes me as odd, that way of thinking!

The only importance that Mandy had was that her actions made Sue Ellen take control of her life and stop drinking. There was zero use for her after that.

‘Disposable peace of facial tissue’. That’s being polite Sue Ellen my love.

Really? JR initially pursued Mandy not the other way around so I wouldn't describe Mandy as a "manipulative homewrecker" but I would describe JR as being bored in his marriage and looking for something more exciting with a younger hot woman rather than with the aging beauty he was married to.

JR definitely should have married Mandy and spared us the horror that was Cally. I guess that Deborah Shelton by then was on the show for a relatively long time and could demand a higher salary so they gave her the chop to keep costs down.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Really? JR initially pursued Mandy not the other way around so I wouldn't describe Mandy as a "manipulative homewrecker" but I would describe JR as being bored in his marriage and looking for something more exciting with a younger hot woman rather than with the aging beauty he was married to.

Yeah, that's how I remember it too. Also wasn't Sue Ellen already living in a separate bedroom? That would explain him being "bored in his marriage."

JR definitely should have married Mandy and spared us the horror that was Cally. I guess that Deborah Shelton by then was on the show for a relatively long time and could demand a higher salary so they gave her the chop to keep costs down.

Cally was nice enough but she had nothing in common with JR - their ages couldn't have been any further apart, the places where they grew up - Braddock - just outside of Dallas - compared to Haleyville were opposites, and their families were opposites.
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
Yeah, that's how I remember it too. Also wasn't Sue Ellen already living in a separate bedroom? That would explain him being "bored in his marriage."
Yes, I think you're right. If Sue Ellen wasn't giving him any nookie was it any surprise with his track record he would go looking for some elsewhere?
Yeah, that's how I remember it too. Also wasn't Sue Ellen already living in a separate bedroom? That would explain him being "bored in his marriage."

Cally was nice enough but she had nothing in common with JR - their ages couldn't have been any further apart, the places where they grew up - Braddock - just outside of Dallas - compared to Haleyville were opposites, and their families were opposites.
Cally was a complete mismatch with JR whereas I could totally see JR and Mandy being happy with Mandy in the long term. She was intelligent, strong and sophisticated and in many ways was a younger version of Sue Ellen without the drink problem and unstable character.
 

Grant Jennings

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
At some point I recall reading that there was some friction between Susan and the powers that be on the series because she'd been unhappy with what she perceived as a pro-choice storyline for Donna. I'm not clear on how - or even if - that played out (did Ray and Donna discuss abortion in Season Eight? Or could the storyline have been changed to the tasteless "gored by a bull" scenario to steer round it?). But if it's true, the complaint would have been another strike against Howard.

As I remember it, the producers didn't want to add another child to the Ewing family but viewers were expecting Ray and Donna to start a family. The writers decided Donna would become pregnant and learn the child had Down Syndrome. They planned to have Donna decide to have an abortion which would - temporarily - cause a rift between her and Ray. Susan Howard is pro-life and refused to go along with this, this is why they wrote the scene with Donna being gored by the bull.

Susan Howard was very vocal about her displeasure with the choice to eliminate everything that happened during the dream season, she thought they should have come up with an alternative that would have allowed Patrick Duffy/Bobby to return while preserving that season's plots.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
I hope everyone realizes that Deborah Shelton and Mandy Winger are two different people (one real, the other fictional).

And even Sue Ellen admitted that she knew Mandy was "sooo beautiful" and "special" over JR's other mistresses.

she-said-it-the-wit-and-wisdom-of-sue-ellen-ewing-4.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Grant Jennings

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
I hope everyone realizes that Deborah Shelton and Mandy Winger are two different people (one real, the other fictional). And even Sue Ellen admitted that she knew Mandy was "sooo beautiful" and special" over JR's other mistresses.

Wait, what?! The characters and the actors are not the same?! This explains a lot. I've often wondered why Major Nelson would leave Jeannie for that drunken slut.
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
As I remember it, the producers didn't want to add another child to the Ewing family but viewers were expecting Ray and Donna to start a family. The writers decided Donna would become pregnant and learn the child had Down Syndrome. They planned to have Donna decide to have an abortion which would - temporarily - cause a rift between her and Ray. Susan Howard is pro-life and refused to go along with this, this is why they wrote the scene with Donna being gored by the bull.

Susan Howard was very vocal about her displeasure with the choice to eliminate everything that happened during the dream season, she thought they should have come up with an alternative that would have allowed Patrick Duffy/Bobby to return while preserving that season's plots.

I wonder why the producers didn't want to add another child to the Ewing clan?
Personally, I would have had so much respect for the writers and everyone involved if they had continued with the Down's Syndrome story and allowed the baby to be born. It could have been handled tastefully and taken persons with Down's Syndrome to be taken "out of the closet," as it were. The Dallas writers and actors have shown they can handle difficult subjects with class(Miss Ellie's breast cancer, for example) without exploiting them. This could have also been one as well. Plus, they had two very talented actors in Mr. Kanaly and Ms. Howard for this particular story.
 

Grant Jennings

Telly Talk TV Fanatic
Howard, Kanaly and Bel Geddes were the actors who kept "Dallas" grounded. I guess the producers didn't want to wrangle a bunch of child actors. It did feel as if John Ross, Christopher and Charlie were more plot devices than actual characters.
 
Last edited:
Top