The Underrated Storylines

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I'll start.
Wes Parmalee
None of the viewers I knew ever bought into the Parmalee as Jock storyline. Sure, there were a few coincidences, but nothing compelling enough to make us believe that Jock really could have come back. So they tied that storyline up in a neat little bow by showing that Parmalee was an imposter after all.
No payoff, just kind of an anticlimactic ending to an idea that fizzled out.

They knew they couldn't make the viewers believe he was Jock. They never even considered having him be Jock. Who could go through that accident, be burned so badly, and not have a single visible scar? There isn't a plastic surgeon in the world who is that good. Besides, Parmalee's entire skeleton was smaller than Jock's.. Jock's frame, his build, was entirely different from Parmalee's. I can't just overlook all that, no Dallas fan could. How would they?

If they ever considered having Parmalee be Jock they would have cast someone with the right build wouldn't they? Because he was so badly burned his face didn't have to look the same (it would need to be scarred badly though) but they can't have the real Jock Ewing come back with his whole skeleton drastically smaller can they?

There is a nice special feature in that DVD where it's explained that they never considered having Parmalee really being Jock. That would have been really cheesy and they knew that. The producer himself explains their intent in the special feature. They hadn't gone through the lengths they did to be respectful to the legacy of Jim Davis by keeping Jock's name talked about every season and by having Jim Davis' portrait always hanging in a place where the viewers saw it so much just so they could take all that work and legacy which said "only Jim Davis can play Jock Ewing" and then turn their backs on all that and replace Jim Davis after all.
 
Last edited:

Frank Underwood

Telly Talk Champion
Another underrated storyline was JR being stuck in the asylum. I loved and hated this plotline in equal amounts but there was some really good stuff amongst the rubbish. It went on way too long, was totally unrealistic and seeing JR so powerless was just wrong. However, the situation he was put in allowed us to see another side to JR which I found fascinating. I loved how he was able to gain the confidence and respect of his fellow inmates and establish friendships with them in a way you never saw with his friends in the oil business. It all culminated his beautiful leaving scene in which he gave them all very well thought out parting gifts and one of them hugs him closely. He then gives a flash of the old JR before going when he threatens the doctor in charge of the facility of what he will do if he mistreats his new mates.
I don't think JR was used to having friends who liked him for him. The cartel never really liked JR, and just used him as a means to power. Of course, JR used them for the same reason.

And while it was interesting seeing a different side to JR, the storyline just didn't fit the show. Perhaps I would have enjoyed it more had it been a stand alone movie with Larry Hagman playing the part of a big time businessman turned mental patient. However, it felt completely out of place as a storyline on Dallas.

I always found it odd that JR started putting himself in situations he couldn't get out of. Just like the mess in Haleyville. If Callie's brothers had warned the old JR to stay away from her, he would have sent someone to take care of them. But the JR of the later seasons ignores them, sleeps with her, and then acts surprised when they pull a shotgun on him.

The asylum plot is even worse because JR actually commits himself! Again, the old JR would have never done that. I know the excuse was that Lady Jessica was denied visitors and refused to sign JR's document given to her by an orderly, but the old JR would have found a way around that. The later years were all about putting JR in unrealistic situations for comedic effect.
 
Last edited:

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
I was trying to quote this yesterday and it all went wrong. It must have been the shock of finding out that JR was married to...JR!!!! :NI:
JR marrying himself would have been almost as unrealistic as him marrying Cally but maybe more entertaining.
 

Toni

Maximum Member
What if JR had had a twin brother? The possibilities would have been incredible...Not a double Rita-style, but a twin brother who was supposedly stillborn. What Falcon Crest did with Richard Channing was even more unlikely and a lot of people seemed to accept it right away (and the FC forum seems to love that twist...). That would have been a good storyline for BBG and Larry. Maybe the JR we saw after Sue Ellen shot him was the twin brother and that´s why he was such a buffoon...I love those old crappy stories with twins...

upload_2019-3-21_19-31-12.jpeg​
 

Seaviewer

Telly Talk Warrior
The episode where Bobby and JR were stuck in the lift was self-indulgent garbage
Having two rivals stuck in a confined situation is a pretty standard trope - much like the It's a Wonderful Life homage that was "Conundrum".

If they ever considered having Parmalee be Jock they would have cast someone with the right build wouldn't they?
Consideration of such details doesn't seem to have been a priority with the other recasts.
 

Luke_Krebbs_Ewing

Telly Talk Champion
I'd be willing to buy that Wes was Jock based on the x-rays and lie detector tests, etc., but...

It's one thing to come back after a few years in the jungle 15 years younger, a few inches shorter, and with a completely different face, but there's no way in *hell* a man would drastically change the way he pronounces the word 'business', no matter what trauma and procedures he's been through!

the real thing: (go to the :38 second mark if the embedded video doesn't start right there)

the impostor: (at the 29 second mark)

Jim Davis's Jock doesn't say business in that first video. So I don't understand where you're coming from. :confused:
 

Frank Underwood

Telly Talk Champion
Having two rivals stuck in a confined situation is a pretty standard trope
That's precisely what was wrong with it. It felt too gimmicky, like something you'd see in a bad sitcom.

- much like the It's a Wonderful Life homage that was "Conundrum".
But without the charm and inspirational message. A series finale revolving around a hallucination, and centering on several characters that never even existed. Worst series finale ever.

Consideration of such details doesn't seem to have been a priority with the other recasts.
I'm glad they at least tried to explain why he looked so different. They didn't make any attempt with the previous recasts.
 

Ollie james

Telly Talk Active Member
I liked the downs syndrome storyline really because at the time it was a subject matter i knew little about. Also the fact it was a story carried by actors outside of the usual JR,Bobby ,Pam or Sue Ellen. We were treated to a powerhouse display of acting from Susan Howard but my question is to the real Dallas experts on tjis forum is this..Does this storyline even really exist in the characters journey due to the fact that the season was written off as a dream?
 

Frank Underwood

Telly Talk Champion
I liked the downs syndrome storyline really because at the time it was a subject matter i knew little about. Also the fact it was a story carried by actors outside of the usual JR,Bobby ,Pam or Sue Ellen. We were treated to a powerhouse display of acting from Susan Howard but my question is to the real Dallas experts on tjis forum is this..Does this storyline even really exist in the characters journey due to the fact that the season was written off as a dream?
No, that storyline was part of the dream. In "reality," Donna had a healthy baby girl named Margaret.

Personally, I wasn't a big fan of that storyline. I thought Susan Howard was a bit hammy at times, which was unlike her. And then they had her miscarry and adopt a deaf kid instead.
 

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I also didn’t like Donna and Ray’s storylines during the dream. It was too much like an Afterschool Special. Very out of place on Dallas.

And why was a pregnant woman hanging around a bull anyway? I think that’s the craziest miscarriage in the history of TV.
 
Last edited:
Top