Who should they have cast as Jamie?

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
I won't argue about Deborah Shelton's beauty, that's not in dispute. I just thought her acting wasn't quite up to scratch. But Pamela Sue Martin as Mandy would have been interesting. The above photo illustrates her similarities to the character of Sue Ellen and I think this would have been an interesting idea to cast an actress who had similar looks to Linda. This would explain J.R.'s attractiveness to her.

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. I'm not saying she isn't attractive but she's certainly not the most beautiful in my eyes. The character is so bloody full of her own self importance that it's all I see, she's hateful. So yes it's in dispute to me.

JR did however pick women who did resemble Sue Ellen in many ways.
 
Last edited:

lbf522

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Jamie coming to Southfork uninvited and expecting them to just accept her just like that bothered me. I would have preferred meeting Jason instead.
 

Presea

Telly Talk Addict
Jamie coming to Southfork uninvited and expecting them to just accept her just like that bothered me. I would have preferred meeting Jason instead.
Exactly. It would have been more believable if the whole branch of that family had been together (as in Jason, Jack, and Jamie) with a real backstory and a way for them all to interact and have more of a story with the Ewings we already had. Jamie's betrayal and marriage to Cliff just isolated her from the Ewings even more. Or they could have just only used Jason and Jack.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
Jamie coming to Southfork uninvited and expecting them to just accept her just like that bothered me.
JR was skeptical even Bobby. Sue Ellen accepted Jamie as her new pet to feed and groom. What I didn't like was the writers air-brushing established characters like Katherine and Afton. The writers allowing Katherine to admit in full view of witnesses her determination to kill Bobby was amateurish. The same could be said of Afton. Years of partnering with Cliff meant nothing; she put on her best Vivian Ward look, spoke a few words with Cliff and left the building.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
JR was skeptical even Bobby. Sue Ellen accepted Jamie as her new pet to feed and groom. What I didn't like was the writers air-brushing established characters like Katherine and Afton. The writers allowing Katherine to admit in full view of witnesses her determination to kill Bobby was amateurish. The same could be said of Afton. Years of partnering with Cliff meant nothing; she put on her best Vivian Ward look, spoke a few words with Cliff and left the building.

I think Afton's last scene was one of her best because she acted so well, looked amazing, and years of waiting to be Cliff's wife while just being his doormat instead finally reached the point where she couldn't take it anymore and rightfully so! She said to Cliff: "You're the coldest man I've ever met" and also told him the only person he ever thinks about is himself. The way Cliff treated Afton was disgraceful.

Someone, maybe @Barbara Fan mentioned that expression Jamie got when she got angry. I remember it. The eyes glared, her mouth fell open while her chin jutted forward and she reminded me of a bulldog.

I have a a couple ideas for Jamie - my first choice (on the left) was Deborah Shelton's co-star in the 1984 movie Body Double and the other is the girl they'd have had to steal from "The Fall Guy"

Melanie-Griffith-before-plastic-surgery-02.jpg 51ny954EzDL._SX342_QL70_.jpg
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I thought the introduction of Peter Richard's was a good one though the choice of Christopher Atkins was poorly executed. I know at the time a lot of fans had issues with the story but once again Dallas proved it was a head of its time. Does the name cougar ring a bell?

Are cougars still a thing anymore? They're the same things MILFS aren't they? I think the story of Sue Ellen with a younger lover could have worked but not with someone young enough to be her son, someone who his friends honestly mistook for his mother. A guy another 5 years older might have worked if he was just into her for sex because older women were his thing could have worked, but Atkins was so damn earnest in his portrayal, as if he expected more than a fling. Like oh sure, this woman married to man who is practically a billionaire is gonna leave him for a camp counselor who wears half shirts. She's gonna pick him to be her 5 year old son's stepfather???

Anyway, regarding Jenilee, I remember the "eeng" thing she did on every word ending in ing. It got to me after a while. The funniest thing would have been for one of the characters to have a scene with her when she's trying to prove she is a genuine Eweeeng, someone like JR or Punk or even Jordan Lee and tell her, "Nobody and I mean nobody in Texas says the word "oil" the way you say it."

Here is a girl who would've been far better than Jenilee Harrison as Jaime. She would have been an amazing addition to the cast. Imagine Victoria Principal, Deborah Shelton, Priscilla Presley Phoebe Cates.jpg th-1.jpeg and this girl all on the same show: The only possible problem is, realistically, how does Cliff not have a heart attack trying to keep up with this woman in bed?
 
Last edited:

James from London

International Treasure
I thought Jamie was fine as she was. Kind of clumsy, kind of awkward, kind of wholesome, she was never gonna be an iconic DALLAS character, but she made an interesting change from the usual supporting female character, especially as you had actual Miss USA coming on at the same time to play Mandy Winger. As the distant, dusty poor relation, it kind of made sense that she wouldn't be as conventionally pretty or sexy in the usual Hollywood conveyer belt sort of way.
 
Last edited:

Chris2

Telly Talk Dream Maker
suzanne-somers-today-5-171113_19ba2c96ac3f1efdafda0e881171816b.fit-1120w.jpg
Suzanne Somers
 
Last edited:

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
Now I see Nicolette Sheridan rollerskating into the Ewing Oil office with a drink for JR. And the message that she's a Ewing and she's come to collect her piece of the pie. Cheers!
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
Jamie and Jack joined the Dallas cast in the mid 1980s when TV was beginning to wake up to the fact that popular drama should be more reflective of modern society and have a more diverse cast. It was the perfect opportunity to introduce biracial actors to play the roles so I would have cast Halle Berry in as Jamie which would have been a few years before she was in Knots Landing.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Jamie and Jack joined the Dallas cast in the mid 1980s when TV was beginning to wake up to the fact that popular drama should be more reflective of modern society and have a more diverse cast It was the perfect opportunity to introduce biracial actors to play the roles so I would have cast Halle Berry in as Jamie which would have been a few years before she was in Knots Landing.

Halle Berry is a fine actress and I especially enjoyed her performance in Monster's Ball which appeared to be an emotionally draining role for any actress. I'd have been glad to see her in Dallas because she is such a quality actress. However, I'm opposed to the idea of hiring a "diverse cast" for the sake of having one. If it naturally turns out that way, great. If it's forced, because they want to meet a certain diversity quota, I've got a real problem with that.

Whether a show's cast is reflective of the various ethnic and racial groups in society is of no consequence to me. I just want to see a good show. I watched and enjoyed The Cosby Show which had no diversity since everyone in it was of the same racial group - black. That wasn't why I liked it; I enjoyed it because it had a good sense of humor and good actors.

Dallas, was far more reflective of our society than The Cosby Show ever was since it was a show filled with mostly white people in a white dominated country. I see nothing wrong with that. I don't think someone's ethnic background should the reason for them being hired and I find the quota policy racist. The actors and actresses who are the best people they can get for a role are the people I would hope they'd hire. I don't need every show I see to have a racially and ethnically diverse cast so I can get used to seeing people of different ancestry interacting with each other. I'm already used to seeing that, since I live just outside of Washington DC which has a disproportionately high black population - roughly 50% black, 40% white, 4% oriental and 6% other.

I don't need TV to "help me get along with minorities." If the most competent actor loses out to in casting to someone less competent because they fit a certain demographic profile, the show and its audience both lose out. I'd never want to think I got a job based on my ancestry; I believe in the merit system.
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
However, I'm opposed to the idea of hiring a "diverse cast" for the sake of having one. If it naturally turns out that way, great. If it's forced, because they want to meet a certain diversity quota, I've got a real problem with that.
But Texas is an ethnically diverse state so it would make perfect sense if Jamie was biracial, either half black, or perhaps even more reflective of Texas's demographic, half Hispanic. Less than half the people in Texas are white but you wouldn't know that from watching the show. So the question shouldn't really be why have more people if colour in Dallas but why were there so few. The introduction of Jack and Jamie was probably the last opportunity to introduce black or Hispanic characters into the family and I thought it was a shame that they never took it.
But the Ewings are not "society", they are a family - and there's nothing unrealistic or convoluted about 100% white families.
Yes but Jack and Jamie were outsiders so it was entirely plausible that Jason could have had biracial children because he didn't mix in the same society circles as Jock. So whereas your point holds for the friends and close relations of Jock, Ellie and their descendants, it would be very different for Jason.
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
I thought Jamie was fine as she was. Kind of clumsy, kind of awkward, kind of wholesome, she was never gonna be an iconic DALLAS character, but she made an interesting change from the usual supporting female character, especially as you had actual Miss USA coming on at the same time to play Mandy Winger. As the distant, dusty poor relation, it kind of made sense that she wouldn't be as conventionally pretty or sexy in the usual Hollywood conveyer belt sort of way.

I agree with this observation. The actress and character grew on me, and she was different from what we usually saw. Also, it made sense that she wasn't glamorously beautiful, given the character and her backstory. She was too good for Cliff.
 

Srqmom

Telly Talk Member
Personally I believe Jenilee was the issue and I also agree the writing of the character was poor. I thought the idea of adding another Ewing was great. I loved how the Ewing family were suspicious of her ancestry but after this, what? In the episode "Jamie" we are about to bid farewell to one our most beloved characters, Katherine. Then this thing (Jamie) walks onto Southfork. There really wasn't anywhere to take the character except to marry Cliff, which they did. Poor choice for Cliff in my opinion.

In hindsight I wonder if it would have been better to swap the characters sex around and have Jack arrive rather than Jamie. By this stage it was 1984 and the youth movement was beginning to ratchet up. We had the likes of Michael Jackson, Madonna, Prince, Sony Walkman's, Boom Boxes.

I thought the introduction of Peter Richard's was a good one though the choice of Christopher Atkins was poorly executed. I know at the time a lot of fans had issues with the story but once again Dallas proved it was a head of its time. Does the name cougar ring a bell? But, I could see what the writers/producers were attempting. The 80's was my era and by introducing characters that I could identify with was a good one.
I don’t mind the cougar idea but def another actor, CA was too small and young looking and his voice was high pitched. He and Linda looked totally mis-matched.
 

Srqmom

Telly Talk Member
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. I'm not saying she isn't attractive but she's certainly not the most beautiful in my eyes. The character is so bloody full of her own self importance that it's all I see, she's hateful. So yes it's in dispute to me.

JR did however pick women who did resemble Sue Ellen in many ways.
Shelton was attractive, could see JR chasing her, not good actress, though. She just keeps wide-eyed and smiley through every line.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
to shake things up, make things more diverse, and tie together two major strands of 80s American popular culture, I would have gone with basketball superstar Patrick Ewing to play the character, which would be named Patrick, not Jamie. The backstory would be that a drunken Jason Ewing had mistakenly adopted Patrick from an orphanage after a long shift at an oil field up north, and even though Patrick ended up growing up with a different family back East, the name change was permanent and Jason was indeed his legal father.

Curious to meet his relatives, Patrick would walk up the Southfork driveway androgynously with a duffel bag one day like Jamie did, but unlike Jamie, the Ewings would at first treat him as an honored guest - he was already famous and about to be quite wealthy and no threat to the Ewing fortune in JR's eyes, and he and Bobby bonded over their experiences with big-time college athletics. That is, until one dinner when JR criticized Patrick's jump shot and Bobby pointed out that he took like 3 steps every time he did that move where he bounds across the lane for the shot and it's outrageous that he never got called for travelling.

Enraged, Patrick would whip out a document asserting Jason owned 1/3 of Ewing oil, and the fight would be on. An upcoming young actress (I was thinking Lucy Liu, but she would have been too young) could have shown up a couple of episodes later as Jamie, just in time to lounge around the pool for a few episodes looking hot before abruptly and inexplicably marrying Cliff Barnes.

JjSzKci.png
2GyDh4t.png

(Patrick seen above about to reject an unwitting Ronald Reagan's one-hand set shot as a Founding Father - Jefferson? - looks on. Would he have done the same to cousin Bobby?)
 
Last edited:
Top