Who should they have cast as Jamie?

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
I don’t mind the cougar idea but def another actor, CA was too small and young looking and his voice was high pitched. He and Linda looked totally mis-matched.

it would have been more interesting to me if Brad Pitt had played Peter instead of Charlie's boyfriend Randy - or at least someone who came across as a virile young man and not a cross between a 10 year-old Boy Scout and a sexless college-age religious missionary. They set up the storyline with that scene where sexually-frustrated Sue Ellen lusted over the young men playing football in slow motion before meeting Peter for the first time, but there didn't seem to be any credible hint of her actually being sexually attracted to/tempted by Peter afterwards - the consummation was 100% emotional blackmail and 0% lust from what I recall. It didn't help that Sue Ellen had that super-butchy look going on that year... although as Willie pointed out above, maybe this was all deliberate.
 
Last edited:

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
Perhaps a better idea would have been to expand the role of Dora Mae. At least she had presence.

Honestly, once they started losing cast members like flies it wouldn't have been a bad idea to start giving the workers at Southfork/Ewing Oil some storylines to expand the cast instead of doing the whole long-lost relatives bit. They would've realistically have had reasons to interact with the Ewings without having to be given too much of a reason why they would hang around. I'm surprised it took until TNTDallas to give them proper storylines, even if Elena was a bit too much of a painful self-insert/Mary Sue.
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
I'm surprised it took until TNTDallas to give them proper storylines
Speaking of NuDallas, they were accused of introducing new characters at the expense of some established characters, but O.Dallas never brought back cousin (!!) Jimmy Mohanan/Monahan.
And why couldn't Jack and Jamie be Garrison Southworth's children?
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
Speaking of NuDallas, they were accused of introducing new characters at the expense of some established characters, but O.Dallas never brought back cousin (!!) Jimmy Mohanan/Monahan.
The difference between Lorimar Dallas and TNT Dallas was one focused primarily on the Ewing family. Secondary characters (though just as important) were never allowed to overshadow the Ewing family. TNT Dallas expanded the characters to such a point the Ewing family became non entities in what is/was the Ewing story.

But we do differ on this Willie...and that's okay.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
The difference between Lorimar Dallas and TNT Dallas was one focused primarily on the Ewing family. Secondary characters (though just as important) were never allowed to overshadow the Ewing family. TNT Dallas expanded the characters to such a point the Ewing family became non entities in what is/was the Ewing story.

But we do differ on this Willie...and that's okay.

The original built value in their characters by focusing on the interactions between the characters so that the audience genuinely liked enough of them so much that the audience felt compelled to watch them every week to see what happened to them. TNT didn't create likable characters and took away the likable aspects of the original characters. TNT didn't know how to create likable characters and didn't understand that people won't watch a show where they don't care what happens to whom.

The test is: Does your show build an audience over time or lose their audience over time?

Original Dallas consistently built a larger audience in its first three years and TNT's audience got smaller in each of its three years. TNT could have stayed in business if it even just maintained the audience it started with but it couldn't even do that.
 
Last edited:

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
The difference between Lorimar Dallas and TNT Dallas was one focused primarily on the Ewing family. Secondary characters (though just as important) were never allowed to overshadow the Ewing family. TNT Dallas expanded the characters to such a point the Ewing family became non entities in what is/was the Ewing story.

But we do differ on this Willie...and that's okay.
I was just being a little cheeky in my cousin Jimmy comment.

But while I could understand the difficulty to digest the Ramos family retcon, the idea that the Rylands shouldn't be there doesn't make sense since they are related to Bobby Ewing's wife. How could she not have her own history, unlike, say, Katherine Wentworth who was simply added to the mix and didn't have a raison d'être in the context of "it should be ALL about the Ewings".
The TNT Ewings had to share significant screen time with the new characters, but they were affected by most (if not all) of the things that happened.
I mean, it's all good and well to show the Ewings, but you also need a story.

Furthermore, trying to cram in as many original characters as possible would give the New Generation Dallas sort of a reunion feel - an attempt to recapture and rehash the feel of O.Dallas. You've had 14 years of that stuff, good stuff, but I prefer something fresh without losing the essence of what Dallas stands for.
I did enjoy Afton and Gary's guest appearances, and it's not like those who didn't appear on the new series were completely ignored or forgotten.
But I have no idea what they could have done with Ray and Lucy without making it feel forced and stale, although I agree that Ray's (Bobby's?) son was a no-brainer.
 

Toni

Maximum Member
images


"Hi! I´m Jamie from the NYC Ewings!
You like my Manolo´s?"​
 

lbf522

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
The difference between Lorimar Dallas and TNT Dallas was one focused primarily on the Ewing family. Secondary characters (though just as important) were never allowed to overshadow the Ewing family. TNT Dallas expanded the characters to such a point the Ewing family became non entities in what is/was the Ewing story.

But we do differ on this Willie...and that's okay.


Yes that bothered me as well. Dallas is suppose to be about the trial and tribulations of the Ewing Family instead in Dallas TNT, we get the never before mentioned Ramos Family walking all over the Ewings and the awful Mexican Cartel mess. There were only three (two after Hagman's death) blood Ewings on the show.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
Yes that bothered me as well. Dallas is suppose to be about the trial and tribulations of the Ewing Family instead in Dallas TNT, we get the never before mentioned Ramos Family walking all over the Ewings and the awful Mexican Cartel mess. There were only three (two after Hagman's death) blood Ewings on the show.
Producers tend to write what they know. Katzman was a white male interested in white males. Cidre was an Hispanic woman interested in Hispanic women.

That may be normal, or at least understandable, but whether it works is a matter of opinion.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Producers tend to write what they know. Katzman was a white male interested in white males. Cidre was an Hispanic woman interested in Hispanic women.

That may be normal, or at least understandable, but whether it works is a matter of opinion.

Katzman was interested in women- didn't he have a thing for Sheree J Wilson? Good thing too, she saved the later years from being hard to watch.

I think it's best to stick what has been proven to work for a particular show. Dallas had a cast of white men and women, had about a 50/50 ratio men to women and it became the most watched show on TV. Why mess with success? It was a modern day western. There haven't been a whole lot of black or oriental westerns, have there? A black cast worked great for The Cosby Show but wouldn't have for a western.
 

lbf522

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I agree they should have kept cousin Jimmy on the show and not limiting it to the Cliff and Pamela representing the Barnes Family.
 

Herofan

Telly Talk Active Member
I won’t critique her acting or general appearance as a reason I would have wanted another actress, but back in the day, the first thing I thought was “Three’s Company.” I couldn’t get that out of my head. She just didn’t seem like a Dallas actress to me.
 

thomaswak

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I was a teenager when Jamie first appeared on Dallas
me and my friends - back in the day - called her the Ugly Ewing!
it was that weak mouth - always open
Nice figure tho lol but she always appeared to be cold with certain features prominent lol

Dont know who i would have preferred in the role
She was one of the first during S7 when i thought the secondary actors werent as good as the first s1-6

With that mouth Jamie surely could have lived in a Southfork barn, unnoticed.
 
Top