Why Lucy Was The Most Expendable Character Of The Main Cast

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Someone once said: "One must feel strongly to make others feel strongly."

They didn't establish Lucy as a character who had any particular ambition in life. If someone had asked Lucy what she wanted to get out of life she probably would have said she didn't know.

Lucy didn't feel strongly enough about anything significant enough to make her character vital to the show.
 

Bobby Southworth

Telly Talk Fan
Top Poster Of Month
I think they made a mistake making her more of a good girl as early as season 2

She wasn't real convincing, or something was a little strange about her acting in the very first episode, but I thought she pulled off the act in "Lessons" pretty well. Maybe the reason her character didn't go real far was because she had no ties to Ewing Oil? I don't know, but you could be right as the lack of ambition being the reason. Maybe it would have been more interesting to see her fight for independence from the Ewing family early on, rather than waiting till season 8 to make her at least start working. Yes, I realize she worked as model before that time, but that never really went anywhere or displayed a real hunger to stand on her own, separate from the Ewings. It could have been interesting to see her either more involved in family business or attempt to stand on her own, or both. I also think, outside of Alan Beam, none of her suitors really helped to make her more interesting. She could have dated guys that would have helped her try to get a slice of the family business, especially with her having more of a bad girl flavor. Perhaps if the guys she dated would have just been a little more interesting in their own right. Mickey ended up being a likable character, but he was written out too soon to see the possibilities there.
 
Last edited:

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I think they made a mistake making her more of a good girl as early as season 2

She wasn't real convincing, or something was a little strange about her acting in the very first episode, but I thought she pulled off the act in "Lessons" pretty well. Maybe the reason her character didn't go real far was because she had no ties to Ewing Oil? I don't know, but you could be right as the lack of ambition being the reason. Maybe it would have been more interesting to see her fight for independence from the Ewing family early on, rather than waiting till season 8 to make her at least start working. Yes, I realize she worked as model before that time, but that never really went anywhere or displayed a real hunger to stand on her own, separate from the Ewings. It could have been interesting to see her either more involved in family business or attempt to stand on her own. I also think, outside of Alan Beam, none of he suitors really helped to make her more interesting. She could have dated guys that would have helped her try to get a slice of the family business, or had just been more interesting characters in their own right.

She did play her role in "Lessons" well! I agree. That was good role for her then - being the rebellious, bad girl. After she graduated though she needed something substantial she was working towards doing - something she felt strongly about, like a career. She had some success in that like becoming Young Miss Dallas, but she was just doing it to help pay the bills while Mitch was in school; it was hardly her life's dream to become a successful model. As a result, any success she had in modeling had a diminished impact.

Then she went from man to man, all vastly different from each other. She didn't have a certain type of man she was hoping to find, so her relationships failed. Mitch's values were incompatible with hers. She tried going out with practically any man she could find. She didn't know what kind of man she was looking for.

I think she had one great relationship - the one with Mickey. He was just the nephew Ray brought there, so it was just chance that she ended up with a guy who suited her well, and because Mickey went after her. I liked her with Mickey, but then Mickey died, and she was back to being a woman with no direction in her life, not knowing who or what she wanted because she hadn't ever set any clear goals for herself. She drifted through life just sort of letting things happen to her instead of having an ambition of trying to make something happen for her. As a result her life had no clear direction or purpose.
 
Last edited:

thomaswak

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Lucy had no idea of what and who she was. Neither the writers. Neither the fans.
Decades later, it's still hard to think or imagine an interesting suiting plot for her.

Anyway, I never ever hated the character. I just didn't care that much. The only moment I really liked her was when she was with Mickey.
 

Justine

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
I don't think it was Lucy's lack of ambition that made her expendable. I think, it was true to her character for her to be very vague and whimsical about her future - she's the eldest grandchild of Jock and Miss Ellie Ewing, destined to inherit part of the family fortune - why would she have plans for the future when she's practically guaranteed to live the life of luxury for the rest of her life?

Decades later, it's still hard to think or imagine an interesting suiting plot for her.

I think the rape/abortion storyline was potentially her best storyline. One that's often batted around on here is the possibility that J.R. could have been Lucy's father and I think that certainly would have had the audiences more interested in her.

She did play her role in "Lessons" well! I agree. That was good role for her then - being the rebellious, bad girl.

She did play the bad girl well and I think that should have continued into adulthood. If she had been J.R.'s daughter, it could have swung either way but it definitely would have been interesting to see Lucy team-up with him.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Lucy had no idea of what and who she was. Neither the writers. Neither the fans.

I think this is the problem. It's not that they didn't like Charlene Tilton, it's just they didn't know what to do with her character.
She did play the bad girl well and I think that should have continued into adulthood. If she had been J.R.'s daughter, it could have swung either way but it definitely would have been interesting to see Lucy team-up with him.

Interesting point. We see Lucy and J.R. sparring with each other, but we never see them team up together. That could have led to some good storylines.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I’m glad they didn’t make her JR’s daughter because that would have killed the backstory of Gary, Valine and Lucy. Shows and movies are always more interesting when there’s a compelling backstory.
 

Rove

Telly Talk Warrior
I’m glad they didn’t make her JR’s daughter because that would have killed the backstory of Gary, Valine and Lucy. Shows and movies are always more interesting when there’s a compelling backstory.

I've always had the opposite thoughts. Making Lucy JR's daughter would have made sense. It could explain why JR had his henchmen get Lucy back to Southfork, why Gary fled and Valene being terrified of JR. Rather than diminish the backstory I think the revelation Lucy was the daughter of JR could have enhanced her prominence especially since she had shares in Ewing Oil.

The writers however stuffed up Lucy's story arc beginning with the revelation Ray was a Ewing :yikey: which appeared to be a desperate measure to keep Ray interesting. I liked Ray in those early episodes lurking in the moonlit shadows of Southfork waiting for JR to exit.

When I watch Lorimar Dallas from the beginning I always see Lucy as the weakest character, it doesn't help her acting chops weren't on par with the likes of Jim, Barbara and others. Her character dithered from vamp to attending high school/college in pigtails. While other characters went from strength to strength it appeared the writers simply ran out of puff when it came to Lucy.

A turning point in her character should have occurred after Mickey's death. Instead Mickey wasn't even cold when the writers thought it a good idea to have Lucy show an interest in Peter.

Finally. If the character was so important why wasn't she packed off to California to be close to her parents Gary and Val. Didn't Lucy always harbour a strong feeling to be reconnected with her parents? Why hang around in Dallas? I never watched Knots Landing to know if Lucy would have been a great fit. Clearly she was no longer wanted in Dallas.
 

Miss Texas 1967

Telly Talk Addict
Finally. If the character was so important why wasn't she packed off to California to be close to her parents Gary and Val. Didn't Lucy always harbour a strong feeling to be reconnected with her parents? Why hang around in Dallas? I never watched Knots Landing to know if Lucy would have been a great fit. Clearly she was no longer wanted in Dallas.

As far as I remember, she went to KL for an episode, Val and Gary treated her like a child which she was too old for and they didn't have an established relationship to make work, so she left and went back to Dallas.

The scene below is at the end of the episode, it doesn't end with them on bad terms, they all just missed the right time to socially experience the relationship they biologically had.

 

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
The writers however stuffed up Lucy's story arc beginning with the revelation Ray was a Ewing :yikey: which appeared to be a desperate measure to keep Ray interesting. I liked Ray in those early episodes lurking in the moonlit shadows of Southfork waiting for JR to exit.

I completely agree. All Ray/Lucy interactions became really awkward after that which was a shame because there was a history there that had to be completely ignored. I also think Ray could've acted as connecting the Ewings more to the workers on the Ranch - as I said in another thread, once actors started dropping off like flies having workers on the ranch as at least recurring characters interacting with the Ewings and maybe even getting their own storylines eventually if the audience responded well to them wouldn't have been the worst idea instead of introducing random characters or inventing new relatives.

Either way, I liked the idea of Lucy becoming a junior exec at Ewing Oil, especially once she returned. Why not really? Why wouldn't Lucy, especially in the later seasons, finally figure that she wanted to try it in the family business after being divorced and feeling directionless? While I couldn't see her going head-to-head with JR I could certainly see her messing with him a bit at the office.

Finally. If the character was so important why wasn't she packed off to California to be close to her parents Gary and Val. Didn't Lucy always harbour a strong feeling to be reconnected with her parents? Why hang around in Dallas? I never watched Knots Landing to know if Lucy would have been a great fit. Clearly she was no longer wanted in Dallas.

To be fair, they did adress that when she appeared on Knots Landing and she just thought she didn't fit in there and in all honesty she (and the writers) were right. She did feel "off" on that show and weirdly enough Kristin seemed to fit in better in the episode she appeared in on Knots.
 
Last edited:

James from London

International Treasure
they all just missed the right time to socially experience the relationship they biologically had.

That's a nice way of putting it. This is what I wrote the last time I watched Lucy's episode of Knots:

No doubt about it, Lucy Ewing's a problematic character. I've said it before and I'll cut and paste it again: "The televisual equivalent of a hothouse flower, she could only ever truly make sense as part the original DALLAS ensemble. She didn't survive on KNOTS LANDING, nor would she on a 21st century DALLAS, God bless her." But actually, her inability to fit in on the cul-de-sac is what this episode is all about. I've always assumed the way Lucy goes completely and totally gaga over her poky new bedroom and a couple of childhood keepsakes - a moth-eaten stuffed rabbit ("Flopsy!!") and a crinoline toilet holder - was down to Charlene Tilton's ridiculous over-acting, and maybe it is a little bit, but it's also Lucy trying to turn back the clock and recreate the idyllic childhood she never had. She spends the whole episode trying on different guises: Mama's little girl cooing over her dolls, spoilt rich bitch maxing out Jock's credit card, Cosmic Steeple gang banger, even a teen activist protesting against the transportation of nuclear waste. That last one was never gonna fly, but I love the exchange between her and Diana where Diana has to explain that the reason she and her friends are campaigning against nuclear waste is because it's dangerous.

The end of the episode - Gary, Lucy and Val running in the ocean - is hokey, bonkers and glorious all at the same time. In hindsight, knowing that Lucy never made it back to KNOTS after this ep, makes this fleeting moment between them all the more precious. This was as good as it ever got between them and that it happens in slow motion and ends in a freeze-frame makes it kinda poignant.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
I've always had the opposite thoughts. Making Lucy JR's daughter would have made sense. It could explain why JR had his henchmen get Lucy back to Southfork, why Gary fled and Valene being terrified of JR. Rather than diminish the backstory I think the revelation Lucy was the daughter of JR could have enhanced her prominence especially since she had shares in Ewing Oil.

The writers however stuffed up Lucy's story arc beginning with the revelation Ray was a Ewing :yikey: which appeared to be a desperate measure to keep Ray interesting. I liked Ray in those early episodes lurking in the moonlit shadows of Southfork waiting for JR to exit.

When I watch Lorimar Dallas from the beginning I always see Lucy as the weakest character, it doesn't help her acting chops weren't on par with the likes of Jim, Barbara and others. Her character dithered from vamp to attending high school/college in pigtails. While other characters went from strength to strength it appeared the writers simply ran out of puff when it came to Lucy.

A turning point in her character should have occurred after Mickey's death. Instead Mickey wasn't even cold when the writers thought it a good idea to have Lucy show an interest in Peter.

Finally. If the character was so important why wasn't she packed off to California to be close to her parents Gary and Val. Didn't Lucy always harbour a strong feeling to be reconnected with her parents? Why hang around in Dallas? I never watched Knots Landing to know if Lucy would have been a great fit. Clearly she was no longer wanted in Dallas.

Lucy simply didn’t fit in Dallas. Someone her age works better in daytime soaps.

JR had Jocks and Miss Ellie’s blessing in sending those henchmen after Valine. They were not about to let someone like Valine raise a Ewing heir on the road.

I recently said, her and Mitch would have fitted in better on Knots Landing. I have no idea why they didn’t move there.
 
Last edited:

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
Lucy simply didn’t fit in Dallas. Someone her age works better in daytime soaps.

JR had Jocks and Miss Ellie’s blessing in sending those henchmen after Valine. They were not about to let someone like Valine raise a Ewing heir on the road.

I recently said, her and Mitch would have fitted in better on Knots Landing. I have no idea why they didn’t move there.

Was it ever established that Jock and Miss Ellie knew and approved of JR taking Lucy against Valene's will? The impression I got was that they may have suspected but chose to remain in denial.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
Was it ever established that Jock and Miss Ellie knew and approved of JR taking Lucy against Valene's will? The impression I got was that they may have suspected but chose to remain in denial.

knowing the dynamics of the Ewings, JR would not have done that without Jock’s approval and Miss Ellie most certainly knew about it. Jock wouldn’t want his granddaughter just living anywhere and Miss Ellie wouldn’t want her granddaughter to have a stable home with family. Also, would JR really give a damn that Gary and Val’s daughter was gone?
 

Toni

Maximum Member
I wonder where Miss Ellie kept her infamous "whip" regarding Jock´s behavior at the time...I always had the impression that it was her who took the best out of him, but sometimes it´s the opposite feeling...

images


"No, wrong number, this is not Southfork, Valene..."​
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
Someone once said: "One must feel strongly to make others feel strongly."

...and no one felt anything more strongly on the show than Lucy did when she wasn't allowed to plan her own birthday party, from choice of guests and music (no Coffins), to even picking out her own clothes for the event.

2_7_8.jpg


on a more serious note, I thought she played the 'bad girl' (or 'tiny sex goblin' as she's called on the Dallas Reviewed site) - even in the 'call me her name' scene - more convincingly than the whiny, unlucky in love semi-idiot teenager/young woman. Tell me the below pic where she's 'persuading' Ray to turn around and make a beeline for the hayloft doesn't look legit

1_2_6.jpg
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I thought she played the 'bad girl' (or 'tiny sex goblin' as she's called on the Dallas Reviewed site) - even in the 'call me her name' scene - more convincingly than the whiny, unlucky in love semi-idiot teenager/young woman. Tell me the below pic where she's 'persuading' Ray to turn around and make a beeline for the hayloft doesn't look legit

I agree, she was very convincing in that role. They would have done well to to continue with that version of Lucy for longer than they did.
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
knowing the dynamics of the Ewings, JR would not have done that without Jock’s approval and Miss Ellie most certainly knew about it. Jock wouldn’t want his granddaughter just living anywhere and Miss Ellie would want her granddaughter to have a stable home with family. Also, would JR really give a damn that Gary and Val’s daughter was gone?
 

Jimmy Todd

Telly Talk Mega Star
That's a nice way of putting it. This is what I wrote the last time I watched Lucy's episode of Knots:

No doubt about it, Lucy Ewing's a problematic character. I've said it before and I'll cut and paste it again: "The televisual equivalent of a hothouse flower, she could only ever truly make sense as part the original DALLAS ensemble. She didn't survive on KNOTS LANDING, nor would she on a 21st century DALLAS, God bless her." But actually, her inability to fit in on the cul-de-sac is what this episode is all about. I've always assumed the way Lucy goes completely and totally gaga over her poky new bedroom and a couple of childhood keepsakes - a moth-eaten stuffed rabbit ("Flopsy!!") and a crinoline toilet holder - was down to Charlene Tilton's ridiculous over-acting, and maybe it is a little bit, but it's also Lucy trying to turn back the clock and recreate the idyllic childhood she never had. She spends the whole episode trying on different guises: Mama's little girl cooing over her dolls, spoilt rich bitch maxing out Jock's credit card, Cosmic Steeple gang banger, even a teen activist protesting against the transportation of nuclear waste. That last one was never gonna fly, but I love the exchange between her and Diana where Diana has to explain that the reason she and her friends are campaigning against nuclear waste is because it's dangerous.

The end of the episode - Gary, Lucy and Val running in the ocean - is hokey, bonkers and glorious all at the same time. In hindsight, knowing that Lucy never made it back to KNOTS after this ep, makes this fleeting moment between them all the more precious. This was as good as it ever got between them and that it happens in slow motion and ends in a freeze-frame makes it kinda poignant.

I always appreciated when KL made references to Lucy. One of my favorite scenes is when Val and Karen are walking on the beach and Val mentions recently speaking to Lucy. Later in the conversation Karen asks her how long it has really been since she's spoken to her daughter. Val replies, "About eight
months "
Nothing else is said which is perfect, imho. All the tragic undercurrents of that relationship are there(not to mention Karen and Valene's wonderful friendship).
I've said many times before that I wish they could have had an episode where Lucy visits just to meet Bobby and Betsy. The KL writers would have done an awesome job of conveying the sad, wistfulness in Lucy as she observes the family of which she could have been a part. She could also interact a bit with Gary, Mack, Lilimae, and Abby. Lucy was pretty good at shooting insightful little barbs, and I'd love to have seen her do that with Abby.
Perhaps after this there could have been a scene where she is back in Dallas talking to Mickey's grave. I did not like how after the writers did such a great job with that relationship, only for in the next season they had Lucy forget him and go chasing after Peter.
 
Last edited:
Top