Why The Fans Could And Did Like JR Ewing

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
It seems counterintuitive, doesn’t it? A character who treats to many people so badly and uses such devious, underhanded tactics in business doesn’t seem like someone you could have as the most central character of a number one rated 1980s primetime series. Granted, Dallas was an ensemble series with an impressive cast, but the most featured character, the one who got the most screen time and whom the other characters talked about the most was JR Ewing. What did it take to make that work?


It took a number of brilliant elements that when combined together, made this character who did so many morally questionable or outright morally wrong things to have been so well liked that people that they’d loyally watch every week for years and have the show do so well it set records for viewership.


Especially in 1978, when moral relativism hadn’t creeped into our culture it in its insidious way, the idea of such a heavily flawed character becoming so popular that it became a pop culture icon and the show becoming the most watched drama series of the 80s would have seemed not just counterintuitive, but impossible. The 1970s were a time when the central character in a series was always a good person, often with many heroic traits. That was what had always worked since the invention of television.


Sometimes what has always worked in the past no longer works or at least becomes not the best way to do things because of a major trend in society, in their culture, that changes what is in demand. Dallas was the innovator in this: they were ahead of their time in recognizing that there was a huge audience for something different.


Why did this particular something different work so well? There are several things about the character that not only made it possible for the audience to like JR, but made them want to like him, made them so fascinated by him that they faithfully tuned in every week to see what he would do next.


A villain, a purely despicable character with no redeeming qualities never would have worked and Dallas would have flopped if they had gone with that approach but instead:


Most fans of anything are casual fans. They want to see a good story. They want to be entertained. America was ready for a "bad guy they could cheer for" - someone who was more bad than good but had enough good in him that they could still cheer him. The good qualities JR had were very good. On the bad side, it was important he had lines he wouldn't cross, like beating his wife, or murder. Cliff would have ended up dead early on in the series, if JR were willing to commit murder. JR never tried to turn John Ross against Sue Ellen. Had JR just been a villain and willing to do any of those things, Dallas would have flopped.


A line JR refused to cross was exemplified when, for example, JR told John Ross that he would never take advantage of Bobby while he was blind. If Bobby hadn’t been his brother, if Bobby had just been some business competitor, JR would have probably exploited the situation, but not when it involved his own brother.


Besides having moral lines he wouldn’t cross, JR had something very powerful on his side: He was sympathetic to the fans. Here’s why:


JR desperately wanted to make his father proud of him. Gary was Ellie's favorite and Bobby was Jock's favorite. That's what made JR so hungry to achieve success - he was the only brother ( before we find out Ray is their brother) who wasn't a favorite of one of his parents. There was something much bigger than money driving JR - it was Jock's love and respect, to have Jock be proud of him. Jock died before JR ever got the feeling that Jock was truly proud of him. So he continually did whatever he could to make Ewing Oil more successful because he never knew how much would be enough to finally make Jock proud of him.


It was brilliant how they did it that way, because it allowed people to have a sympathy for JR that they never would have had if Jock's favorite had been JR and if Jock ran down Bobby for being too nice. It makes it possible for the audience to have sympathy for JR despite his underhanded and even cruel tactics. He's the son that got left out, the victim of his parents’ favoritism. Their favoritism helped make JR what he became. If Jock's favorite had been JR and Jock had continually run Bobby down for being too nice or too weak, it would never have worked!


Even in season 4 when Bobby handed back the reigns to JR and told Jock he wanted out of Ewing Oil, Jock didn't react by being disappointed in Bobby for being "weak." Instead, Jock praised Bobby, even as Bobby quit. Jock said: "I'm proud of Bobby; he showed people Ewing Oil stands for something! He's a hell of a son, a hell of a man."


Bobby had basically emotionally extorted Jock by threatening to leave if Jock didn't let him keep JR's job as long as he wanted. Miss Ellie said said she'd never forgive Jock if Bobby left and Bobby used that to his advantage. That made fans angry at Bobby at that particular time. He was using his own brother getting shot to steal his job and then using Miss Ellie's fear of Bobby leaving to emotionally blackmail Jock - his own father. Then to top it off, he tries to embarrass Jock in front of his friends!


After Bobby doing all those things to Jock, Jock's ultimate reaction was "He's a hell of a son, a hell of a man"! If I'm JR I'm thinking: "How the hell can I ever compete when in Daddy's eyes, Bob can do no wrong"?


Who couldn’t feel sympathy for someone in that situation?


It also helps delineate one of the huge differences between Jock and JR. Can you picture JR being proud of himself for showing people Ewing Oil stands for something??? JR idolizes a man whom he loves with all his heart but just can’t quite understand. If JR can’t understand why Jock would say that, he doesn’t understand what it would even take to finally make Jock proud of him. JR has tried to learn from Jock, but for some reason, JR is unteachable when it comes to the ethical, integrity related issues Jock tries to teach him. JR would do anything to gain his father’s approval and respect but he’s got a blind spot here: He doesn’t understand that these integrity and ethics related issues are vital for him to learn or why they’re so crucial. At one point early in the series JR actually asks his father why it’s important to learn the art of subtlety! As intelligent as he is, JR has a weakness here – something he doesn’t understand and cannot learn. That makes him relatable because who is good at everything?


You could hate JR's methods but admire qualities he had.


I think what that comes down to, at bottom, is competence. JR was just so good at what he did that back in 1978 you couldn't help but wish: Wouldn't it be great if I could get whatever I went after? Also it was the late 70s. Wouldn't it be great if we had someone that competent to deal with the hostage crisis or the bad economy? He may not accomplish it in a way that you'd admire, but you'd be grateful for the end result of having the hostages freed, or having the economy rise out of it's slump and start booming again.


The audience could appreciate how JR was so good about keeping his composure. No matter how hard people tried to get under his skin, or rattle him, all they'd get from JR is a grin. Wouldn't it be great to never let anyone know they've gotten to you? To respond to crisis situations calmly and with a genuine belief that you will prevail?

Cliff constantly reacted with outbursts of anger and a loss of control and good judgement. There was nothing remotely cool about Cliff. There may be a picture of Cliff Barnes next to “antonym for cool.” Who would wanna be like Cliff Barnes?


You could hate JR's methods but admire that coolness, that certain smooth way of doing things with a sense of style, charm and that grin. That shows you - this is a guy who's loving life! That made him far more likable than if Hagman had portrayed JR as being miserable and bitter.


Finally, also unlike Cliff and some others, JR didn't pretend to be a saint. He didn't act sanctimonious and judge other people's morality. It was kind of like: "Here's what you get with me. You may or may not like it, but it's what I am and I make no apologies for it."

It was amazing how well Dallas combined all those elements into one character and how remarkably well Larry Hagman portrayed the character. With a different actor, the character may not have worked. It was a perfect combination of a character with the right elements, and the right actor who understood how to play that character exactly the way it needed to be played.
 
Last edited:

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
Excellent points, all of which makes it even more disappointing that the character of JR became a whipping boy in the last few seasons.
Can you imagine the early series JR allowing himself to be tried by a kangaroo court in Haleyville?

Swami
 

lbf522

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Larry Hagman and the writers were careful with JR Ewing. He was a lovable rogue who did things many could only dream of. He was not over the top evil so that made it easier to root for him. Yes the Haleyville was the start of the destruction of JR Ewing and it was awful how JR was put through this and never sought revenge. The sheriff even had the nerve to come to JR's office with no repercussions.

Having JR lose to every Tom, Dick or Harry was hard to watch.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
I watched a superb scene recently between JR and Sly - JR has discovered Sly has been leaking info to Cliff Barnes, Sly rightly expects to be fired, but when Sly tells JR why she did it, JR is surprisingly understanding.

It would have been so easy for JR just to sack Sly, but instead he turns the situation to his advantage.

Swami
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Larry Hagman and the writers were careful with JR Ewing. He was a lovable rogue who did things many could only dream of. He was not over the top evil so that made it easier to root for him.

That's a good observation. An over the top evil JR would never have made Dallas the success it became. They were careful to keep him from crossing over the line to where it wouldn't have worked.

Having JR lose to every Tom, Dick or Harry was hard to watch.

It was disappointing to see what had been such a compelling character be relegated to what they made him in the last few years. There's a general rule of thumb: "If it ain't broke, don't try to fix it." There's a strong correlation between how competent they allowed JR to be and how big their audience was. As JR lost competency, Dallas lost viewers.
 
Last edited:

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
JR had his two soft spots - John Ross and Miss Ellie/Jock. As you say, without that area of vulnerability, the character would not have been nearly as convincing.

Swami
 

Billy Wall

Telly Talk Dream Maker
JR had his two soft spots - John Ross and Miss Ellie/Jock. As you say, without that area of vulnerability, the character would not have been nearly as convincing.

Swami

IMO, JR’s only soft spot was Ewing Oil/Jock. He definitely loved John Ross and Miss Ellie, but he was infatuated with Jock.

He had no problem putting John Ross on the back burner when that idiot James showed up and he eventually drove Miss Ellie away.

Interesting, I’m watching season 11/episode 22 Crime Story....

JR: “There’s only two things in my life that I love, Ewing Oil and John Ross.”

Sue Ellen: “Probably in that order.”
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
Although he reminds Sue Ellen on the eve of Jock’s trial that everything he does he does for Jock.

Swami
 

lbf522

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
IMO, JR’s only soft spot was Ewing Oil/Jock. He definitely loved John Ross and Miss Ellie, but he was infatuated with Jock.

He had no problem putting John Ross on the back burner when that idiot James showed up and he eventually drove Miss Ellie away.

Interesting, I’m watching season 11/episode 22 Crime Story....

JR: “There’s only two things in my life that I love, Ewing Oil and John Ross.”

Sue Ellen: “Probably in that order.”

I hated the introduction of James Beaumont as JR's son. First , it was not believable that JR would just accept this person as his son after he was suspicious of cousin Jamie. Also, it destroyed JR and John Ross's relationship. I hated how JR treated him after first James's introduction and then James's son.
 

Lastkidpicked

Telly Talk Dream Maker
It was amazing how well Dallas combined all those elements into one character and how remarkably well Larry Hagman portrayed the character. With a different actor, the character may not have worked. It was a perfect combination of a character with the right elements, and the right actor who understood how to play that character exactly the way it needed to be played.

You have summed up J.R. Ewing and Larry Hagman perfectly, Kenny.

Good old J.R.
That magnificent bastard.

They could even put that on his headstone!
 
Last edited:

Toni

Maximum Member
I watched a superb scene recently between JR and Sly - JR has discovered Sly has been leaking info to Cliff Barnes, Sly rightly expects to be fired, but when Sly tells JR why she did it, JR is surprisingly understanding.

It would have been so easy for JR just to sack Sly, but instead he turns the situation to his advantage.

Swami

But he did sack Sly again, didn´t he (and shag her once too if I remember well...)?
 

Willie Oleson

Telly Talk Schemer
and the right actor who understood how to play that character exactly the way it needed to be played
I'm not sure if they know beforehand exactly what that result should be like. Good casting can be anticipated, but that magical perfect casting is usually a hindsight thing because the actor has been able to co-create their character.
To compare, I don't think anyone would have expected more or less from Barbara Bell Geddes - that was good, sensible casting. She could do it and she did it.
Larry Hagman (and Linda Gray too, let's be honest) now that was something else.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I watched a superb scene recently between JR and Sly - JR has discovered Sly has been leaking info to Cliff Barnes, Sly rightly expects to be fired, but when Sly tells JR why she did it, JR is surprisingly understanding.

It would have been so easy for JR just to sack Sly, but instead he turns the situation to his advantage.

Swami

JR, considering hw he treated most non-family members, treated Sly remarkably well. He was polite to her, he was considerate to her, he raised her pay, he gave her bonuses and he never tried to use his position as the boss to get Sly to have sex with him in any case where she didn't also want to have sex with him.

If JR had treated everyone like he treated Sly, he would have had a reputation as a very nice man. Even when he found out Cliff had blackmailed Sly into giving away Ewing Oil secrets to Cliff, JR was very understanding and reasonable with her. Not only did he not fire her, but he actually gave her bonuses to continue talking to Cliff while giving Cliff information JR wanted Cliff to have.
 

Swami

Telly Talk Supreme
JR, considering hw he treated most non-family members, treated Sly remarkably well. He was polite to her, he was considerate to her, he raised her pay, he gave her bonuses and he never tried to use his position as the boss to get Sly to have sex with him in any case where she didn't also want to have sex with him.

If JR had treated everyone like he treated Sly, he would have had a reputation as a very nice man. Even when he found out Cliff had blackmailed Sly into giving away Ewing Oil secrets to Cliff, JR was very understanding and reasonable with her. Not only did he not fire her, but he actually gave her bonuses to continue talking to Cliff while giving Cliff information JR wanted Cliff to have.

To be fair, JR was usually very loyal to all those who were loyal to him.

Swami
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
You have summed up J.R. Ewing and Larry Hagman perfectly, Kenny.

Good old J.R.
That magnificent bastard.

They could even put that on his headstone!

Thank you @Lastkidpicked! That's quite a compliment. After a dozen years on this forum sometimes I wonder if I've got anything new to say about Dallas. There are thousands of threads on Dallas now, so coming up with an idea for a thread that's distinct and original, that offers people value and is fun to read at the same time becomes more challenging the longer we're here on this forum.

It's always been my opinion that if you didn't like JR Ewing, you didn't watch Dallas. After all, if someone's reason for watching was to see someone "stop JR" (as the other characters always liked to put it) then they weren't going to be too satisfied with what the show had in store for them!

I thought to myself: "How is it that a character could behave in so many socially unacceptable ways, and not only be so watchable, but so likable in spite of of it all"?

That was the idea that started this thread. That's what led to what you just read. Taking something that seems so counterintuitive, and just knowing: "There must be some distinctly identifiable reasons why so many people would respond to that character so positively for so long" is what made this thing happen. That anyone would say what you did in response to reading what I wrote makes it worthwhile.
 
Last edited:

Laurie Marr

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Hagman’s performance is a huge part of what made the character so watchable. It’s the lightness that Hagman brings to the role that is so counterintuitive yet so compelling - and which makes those rarer moments of raw malevolence so much more chilling. JR was immensely charismatic and so was Hagman’s performance.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Hagman’s performance is a huge part of what made the character so watchable. It’s the lightness that Hagman brings to the role that is so counterintuitive yet so compelling - and which makes those rarer moments of raw malevolence so much more chilling. JR was immensely charismatic and so was Hagman’s performance.

I agree. It's difficult to imagine Dallas with any other actor playing the role of JR. I don't think they realized exactly what they had when they started out. From what I've read, David Jacobs' original plan for Dallas was for Pam and Bobby to be the two most central characters of the ensemble. They were the two characters who would be featured the most. With Larry Hagman being best known for his work in "I Dream Of Jeannie", I don't think any of them realized how much untapped potential he had for this new role in this new show in 1978.

I've got to give them all credit for quickly realizing that they did have something special with Larry Hagman as JR Ewing, that they had this immensely charismatic actor in the perfect role for him and utilizing him so effectively. They were smart enough to allow him creative input on his character. Then Larry Hagman, for him to have such a good feel for how to best play his character, to know when the script had something that he didn't think JR would say and to then ad lib in his distinct way until it came across as authentic and convincing is so impressive. They gave him the role of a lifetime and Larry Hagman made the most of it by far.
 
Last edited:

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
Hagman’s performance is a huge part of what made the character so watchable. It’s the lightness that Hagman brings to the role that is so counterintuitive yet so compelling - and which makes those rarer moments of raw malevolence so much more chilling. JR was immensely charismatic and so was Hagman’s performance.

Rewatching some of the miniseries recently, I was struck by the fact that Larry/JR didn't show any of that lightness (that I can recall) until Barbecue. He was mainly just grumpy for the first 4 episodes. I'm not sure he even cracked a smile until the Ewing Barbecue was in full swing, when suddenly we see him literally in rose-colored glasses, effortlessly schmoozing with a senator.

Iza7HMO.png
UhxrDhT.png
 

Laurie Marr

Telly Talk Well-Known Member
Rewatching some of the miniseries recently, I was struck by the fact that Larry/JR didn't show any of that lightness (that I can recall) until Barbecue. He was mainly just grumpy for the first 4 episodes. I'm not sure he even cracked a smile until the Ewing Barbecue was in full swing, when suddenly we see him literally in rose-colored glasses, effortlessly schmoozing with a senator.

Iza7HMO.png
UhxrDhT.png
Absolutely true. Well observed. I don’t think Hagman developed the character fully until the first series was underway. None of the characters are particularly well defined in the mini series apart from Pamela. That’s as it should be as her encounter with this strange and intimidating family was the perspective that was also shared by the viewers.
 
Top