Would Dallas be in danger of removal from streaming services?

Toni

Maximum Member
Insults are becoming more and more frequent in these forums. I wonder if it´s time to leave the boat.

upload_2020-6-11_15-35-40.jpeg​
 

Toni

Maximum Member
Racism both thinly veiled and blatant is rampant on these forums.
Also homophobia and xenophobia for many years, and nobody seemed to care, especially some mods. Oh and obviously you are not fat...:re::re:
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
I'm an overweight guy, and shows like Married With Children, Roseanne, and Fresh Prince of Bel Air all poked fun at fat people. I demand that they be pulled from the air, and no thin person is allowed to have an opinion about it because that's the way the world works. Instead of choosing not to watch shows I find offensive, I demand no one else can watch them either.

Breaking Bad is one of the most revered shows of all time, and many of the show's drug kingpins were either black or hispanic. Is it the next to go? Where's the line, or does a line exist?

It's certainly a great day to be an SJW because free speech is taking a back seat to muh feelings. It's not enough to clean up the real world, so I guess we have to sanitize fiction too.
I'm not in favour of fat shaming or mocking people who carry some excess kilograms but it's not really comparable with anti-black racism. Fat people are not twice as likely to be unemployed than other people, fat people aren't more likely to be suspended from school that other students, fat people who are found guilty of crimes are not more likely to get a harsher sentence that other people and fat drivers are not 30% more likely to be pulled over that slimmer ones. Making a joke about a fat person is not the same as perpetuating a white supremacist agenda.

People talk about free speech like it doesn't apply to black people. Black people living in a racist society complaining about racists portrayals in entertainment also have a right to say when things should change. TV has a choice: it can continue to perpetuate the systemic racism that has existed in the industry forever or it can change to bring about more racial equality. People need to used their voices to ensure the latter is the choice they make.
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
Insults are becoming more and more frequent in these forums. I wonder if it´s time to leave the boat.

This is how it works for people who are resistant to accepting equality in diversity. When people challenge them they create a hostile environment to force people away from the discussion or to close it down. That way nothing changes so they win by default.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
Fat people were not ripped from their home lands and kept as stock by white people as slaves you moron! You're imaginary hypothetical slights are not the same thing as very real black oppression. You racist idiot.


There is not one person in our populace who was ever a slave. Why do feel the need to use things that happened in the mid-19th century as a crutch? Insulting him or me doesn't help you come across as credible.

If you think child pornography would perpetuate the abuse of children, why can't you not recognise that shows depicting black people negatively can perpetuate anti-black racism?

The distinction there is to make child pornography, people have to break the law and use children to make pornography. I take a dim view of pornography but at least adult pornography it is consensual. I think pornography is a disgusting form of entertainment that caters to the most depraved sorts, but as long as it is consensual, it doesn't infringe on anyone's rights. Child pornography actually infringes on the rights of children. They're not old enough to give consent. It infringes on the rights of any children involved.

Depicting a fictional character negatively in a movie doesn't infringe on anyone's rights. It doesn't perpetuate racism because it's fictional. The actors willingly participated in the movie. The audience willingly bought tickets to see it while others decided it wasn't a movie that appealed to them. The both had the option to see it or not see it.

That's distinctly different from someone saying that because the movie doesn't appeal to them, nobody should be allowed to see it. A free country country can't operate that way. How would you choose who gets to decide who gets to decide what movies are offensive and therefore can't bee seen by anyone? Wouldn't they have to see the movie to know it is offensive to them? By what right could they watch the movie while other adults could not?
 

Alexis

Telly Talk Superhero
There is not one person in our populace who was ever a slave. Why do feel the need to use things that happened in the mid-19th century as a crutch? Insulting him or me doesn't help you come across as credible.
Nothing you say is credible. You have already proven in various threads that you are sexist, chauvinist and now a racist.
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
Depicting a fictional character negatively in a movie doesn't infringe on anyone's rights. It doesn't perpetuate racism because it's fictional.
I don't know what your race is but that's not the experience of many black people. When I was at school I was often taunted with racist insults that appeared in films and TV. Whenever Gone With The Wind was on TV I could guarantee that someone would call me a "darkie" the next day.

What about the rights of black people not to have to endure being treated like a piece of dirt.
 

Alexis

Telly Talk Superhero
There is not one person in our populace who was ever a slave
A lot of African American's are descended from Slaves.
Insulting him or me doesn't help you come across as credible.
He trivialised Black Lives Matter and things that are occurring right now, by comparing his offence of jokes about overweight people on sitcoms to the attacking, mocking and racist portrayal of black people in TV and film. They are not the same thing. It appeared he needed that explained to him in the bluntest terms.
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
There is not one person in our populace who was ever a slave. Why do feel the need to use things that happened in the mid-19th century as a crutch? Insulting him or me doesn't help you come across as credible.
Well that's a load of small round spherical objects.

If by your populace you mean the USA, it is estimated that over 400,000 people in the USA live in modern slavery as a result of forced labour conditions. And guess what, this impacts disproportionately more on black, Asian and other minority ethnic people.
 

Snarky Oracle!

Telly Talk Supreme
You being fat has nothing to do with your race. It has no links to a past of oppression and slavery. You being fat has nothing to do with racial segregation. You being FAT has no relevance in this conversation. Fat people were not ripped from their home lands and kept as stock by white people as slaves you moron! You're imaginary hypothetical slights are not the same thing as very real black oppression. You racist idiot.
Wow.
 

Taylor Bennett Jr.

Telly Talk Winner
this thread has 'Dallas' in the title and started out in the context of Dallas discussion, but is long past the point where it belongs in any of a number of these other forums/rooms - the lounge? rant room? one of the politics ones? headline news? private messages?

ASQCr8k.png
 
Last edited:

Alexis

Telly Talk Superhero
That's distinctly different from someone saying that because the movie doesn't appeal to them, nobody should be allowed to see it. A free country country can't operate that way. How would you choose who gets to decide who gets to decide what movies are offensive and therefore can't bee seen by anyone? Wouldn't they have to see the movie to know it is offensive to them? By what right could they watch the movie while other adults could not?
Nobody is stopping anyone from seeing GWTW. It's not being banned. And Song Of The South was pulled by Disney, one would assume because they themselves found it offensive.
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
I don't know what your race is but that's not the experience of many black people. When I was at school I was often taunted with racist insults that appeared in films and TV. Whenever Gone With The Wind was on TV I could guarantee that someone would call me a "darkie" the next day.

What about the rights of black people not to have to endure being treated like a piece of dirt.

That's a shame that that happened to you. Individuals are accountable for their own actions. I don't know if there was any disciplinary action taken by the school authorities against people who did that to you or not. People have take accountability for their own actions. A movie is not accountable for their actions. If a movie or a TV show could be held accountable for the actions of individuals, then nobody would have to take self-accountability and instead they could blame movies and TV shows.

You can see people committing crimes with guns on a huge variety of modern day TV shows, but when kids go to their schools with guns and murder dozens of their classmates, the kids can't claim it wasn't their fault because a movie or TV show "made them do it"or even "gave them the idea." That isn't a valid defense. We can't give up our rights to enjoy the entertainment we enjoy because a few people can't control themselves. The innocent cannot be made to pay for the crimes of the guilty. If our country were to start operating on a system where people could refuse to take self-accountability for what they do and instead blame a movie or a show, we would first have to get rid of the First Amendment of the Constitution of the United States of America. It would be not only the end of our entertainment industry as we know it but the end of freedom and liberty.
 
Last edited:

Alexis

Telly Talk Superhero
That's a shame that that happened to you. Individuals are accountable for their own actions. I don't know if there was any disciplinary action taken by the school authorities against people who did that to you or not. People have take accountability for their own actions. A movie is not accountable for their actions. If a movie or a TV show could be held accountable for the actions of individuals, then nobody would have to take self-accountability and instead they could blame movies and TV shows.

You can see people committing crimes with guns on a huge variety of modern day TV shows, but when kids go to their schools with guns and murder dozens of their classmates, the kids can't claim it wasn't their fault because a movie or TV show "made them do it"or even "gave them the idea." That isn't a valid defense. We can't give up our rights to enjoy the entertainment we enjoy because a few people can't control themselves. The innocent cannot be made to pay for the crimes of the guilty. If our country were to start operating on a system where people could refuse to take self-accountability for what they do and instead blame a movie or a show, we would first have to get rid of the First Amendment of the Constitution of the United States of America. It would be not only the end of our entertainment industry as we know it but the end of freedom and liberty.
I am sorry but this is a completely racist point of view. I am offended by this as a white person. It's smug, patronising and obviously from the point of view of someone who has never had to face any discrimination.
 
Moderation comment:

Several comments made within this thread focus on the individual rather than the points being made.

In the spirit of healthy discussion, participants are asked to refrain from making personal comments. No matter how strongly you may disagree with someone's outlook, please find a way to make your point without criticising the individual. This will only serve to undermine any valid point you may have and result in posts being deleted altogether.

In addition, please refrain from criticism of the site or the way it is moderated. For inappropriate posts there is a Report function as well as the option to send a private message to a staff member with any concerns.

I encourage participants to re-read the first posts in this thread to keep discussion on-topic.




We don't wish to stifle discussion and rely on individuals to self-censor and discuss appropriately. I would, however, draw your attention to the following points from our terms of service.


Always respect the views of other participants even if they don’t agree with you. It’s okay to disagree with other members, in fact we encourage debate, just keep the dialogue positive. Always focus on the logic of the argument rather than the individuals involved in the argument. Simply put, treat others as you would be treated; respect them and their views, even if you disagree with them.

Don’t defame anyone or any organisation. A comment is defamatory if it lowers or harms the reputation of a person or organisation. If you wish to accuse someone of committing a crime or being an idiot, this is not the place to do it.

Please be respectful of the moderation team, and do not register complaints about the site, its moderators or members within threads on the site. Please take such issues to a moderator via PM
 

Kenny Coyote

Telly Talk Star
this thread has 'Dallas' in the title and started out in the context of Dallas discussion, but is long past the point where it belongs in any of a number of these other forums/rooms - the lounge? rant room? one of the politics ones? headline news? private messages?

ASQCr8k.png

You're absolutely right, @Taylor Bennett Jr. The discussion that's taking place in this thread now is not about Dallas. It started out related to Dallas, but it isn't about Dallas now. There are other forums right here on this site where it would be far more appropriate. Out of respect to the rest of the people in the Dallas forum who don't come to the particular forum devoted to Dallas discussion for this type of content, I'm going to lead by example and voluntarily stop posting in this particular thread any further, unless it once again becomes Dallas related.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
If you think child pornography would perpetuate the abuse of children, why can't you not recognise that shows depicting black people negatively can perpetuate anti-black racism?

What I’m saying is to make child pornography, it’s the act of making it that is the issue and distributing only causes more to be made. I’m sure depicting black people negatively can perpetuate racism but the act of making it does not have the same concern. I for one would not support such, either to consciously make it myself or distribute as a private citizen. But that does not mean I would censor it. I’d label it so people know what it is. I’d call it out when I see it no matter how much I might like the story around it. But I would never support censoring (the government removing it from the people) anything from an adult audience, other than child pornography as I mentioned because of harm caused in making it. It is not up to the government to protect or guide the thinking of its people but it certainly it up to the government to protect its children from abuse.

So my point being, there is nothing about Dallas or any of these soap which a government should sensor but private businesses should be free to pull them if they wish and have no need to explain.
 
Last edited:
Top