Would Dallas be in danger of removal from streaming services?

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
That's a shame that that happened to you. Individuals are accountable for their own actions. I don't know if there was any disciplinary action taken by the school authorities against people who did that to you or not. People have take accountability for their own actions. A movie is not accountable for their actions. If a movie or a TV show could be held accountable for the actions of individuals, then nobody would have to take self-accountability and instead they could blame movies and TV shows.

You can see people committing crimes with guns on a huge variety of modern day TV shows, but when kids go to their schools with guns and murder dozens of their classmates, the kids can't claim it wasn't their fault because a movie or TV show "made them do it"or even "gave them the idea." That isn't a valid defense. We can't give up our rights to enjoy the entertainment we enjoy because a few people can't control themselves. The innocent cannot be made to pay for the crimes of the guilty. If our country were to start operating on a system where people could refuse to take self-accountability for what they do and instead blame a movie or a show, we would first have to get rid of the First Amendment of the Constitution of the United States of America. It would be not only the end of our entertainment industry as we know it but the end of freedom and liberty.
The abundance of and the casual way in which guns are used in films and TV can glamourise the weaponry and desensitise people to the dangers of firearms. There have been many cases of shooting and other real world crimes that have been inspired by someone watching something in a film or TV show. The idea that films should depict anything they like because it's just fiction and so it won't impact on human behaviour just doesn't stand up to scrutiny.
 

Alexis

Telly Talk Superhero
What I’m saying is to make child pornography, it’s the act of making it that is the issue and distributing only causes more to be made. I’m sure depicting black people negatively can perpetuate racism but the act of making it does not have the same concern.
Oh but it does! How can you not see that?
 

Angela Channing

Telly Talk Veteran
What I’m saying is to make child pornography, it’s the act of making it that is the issue and distributing only causes more to be made. I’m sure depicting black people negatively can perpetuate racism but the act of making it does not have the same concern. I for one would not support such, either to consciously make it myself or distribute as a private citizen. But that does not mean I would censor it. I’d label it so people know what it is. I’d call it out when I see it no matter how much I might like the story around it. But I would never support censoring (the government removing it from the people) anything from an adult audience, other than child pornography as I mentioned because of harm caused in making it. It is not up to the government to protect or guide the thinking of its people but it certainly it up to the government to protect its children from abuse.

So my point being, there is nothing about Dallas or any of these soap which a government should sensor but private businesses should be free to pull them if they wish and have no need to explain.
The subtext to your point is that children are more protected by the law than black people and that's probably the right balance to have but not having adequate protections against racism doesn't make it any more acceptable.

Making and distributing racist material is permitted by law and the fact that far right groups do this indicates that they think it can influence public attitudes and behaviours. So it's not a big jump to recognise that racist depictions in TV and films can influence the viewer's perception of black, Asian and minority ethnic people. I'm not for censoring if it's an accurate depiction of the reality but it's important to give it context.

I agree with your point about Dallas. I think the only offensive thing I can recall is the term JR used to describe gay men. but I think that was in keeping with his character. However, there should have been someone in that scene to challenge his use of the word so the viewer was clear that it was unacceptable..
 
Last edited:

stevew

Telly Talk Star
The subtext to your point is that children are more protected by the law than black people and that's probably the right balance to have but not having adequate protections against racism doesn't make it any more acceptable.

Making and distributing racist material is permitted by law and the fact that far right groups do this indicates that they think it can influence public attitudes and behaviours. So it's not a big jump to recognise that racist depictions in TV and films can influence the viewer's perception of black, Asian and minority ethnic people. I'm not for censoring if it's an accurate depiction of the reality but it's important to give it context.

I agree with your point about Dallas. I think the only offensive thing I can recall is the term JR used to describe gay men. but I think that was in keeping with his character. However, there should have been someone in that scene to challenge his use of the word so the viewer was clear that it was unacceptable..

I agree with you 100% that someone should have at some point called it out for what was, at least before the story arc ended. I also agree with you that such can influence the public. But I do not believe the government is in a position to determine accuracy. It do not see how it can do such and maintain the 1st Amendment. This is why people must speak up when they see something.

Recently I made a comment about the Elena character in TNT. This is a character I did not like at first but grew to like as she became more angry, even if misguided. It made her seem more interesting at least. But toward the end of the series she came across John Ross who was up set and drinking. She egged in the drinking to get him into bed to get what she wanted. Now he may or may not have wanted sex with her but he was in no state of mind to make that call. And the fact that she was sober and encouraging him to drink bothered me. Because if it were reversed he would have been accused of raping her, and I believe rightfully so. I pointed this out, some disagree. It was never addressed in the show (though to be fair it was canceled, they also didn’t address a similar act from season. Could this influence people to do such? Yes. Do I speak out about such? Yes (obviously, lol). Would I support a private enterprise removing it? Yes. Do I support a government censors it? No.
 

Alexis

Telly Talk Superhero
The government isn't censoring anything though. Private streaming and entertainment companies are reviewing their content and making decisions about what is and what isn't offensive and are addressing that.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
Oh but it does! How can you not see that?

Because the act of making it is not abuse. The adults involved are of age and ability (assuming not drugged up) to remove themselves. If those making it are forced to do it or drugged or some such, I’d agree regarding the act of making it. But I do t support censorship. Censorship allows such behavior to hide. I’m all for hate groups speaking out. Say it loud. Then good people can stand up and stop you. Like with Blake in that library scene - good people can begin the outrage and did. But if we sensor it we not only risk good positions (which are subjective) being censored, we risk “bad” ones going into bidding.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
The government isn't censoring anything though. Private streaming and entertainment companies are reviewing their content and making decisions about what is and what isn't offensive and are addressing that.

And I’ve said I agree with that - support that right, tell from the rafters about time, and go as far as to say they don’t have to explain themselves to anyone but their owners.
 

Alexis

Telly Talk Superhero
Because the act of making it is not abuse. The adults involved are of age and ability (assuming not drugged up) to remove themselves. If those making it are forced to do it or drugged or some such, I’d agree regarding the act of making it. But I do t support censorship. Censorship allows such behavior to hide. I’m all for hate groups speaking out. Say it loud. Then good people can stand up and stop you. Like with Blake in that library scene - good people can begin the outrage and did. But if we sensor it we not only risk good positions (which are subjective) being censored, we risk “bad” ones going into bidding.
You don't understand. If a white actor is in blackface and is mocking of someone's race that is abuse! There have been television shows where that has been the case. White people playing black or Asian people in a mocking way. That is abusive and it contributes to a culture of bulling and discrimination. School children see it, and go on to replicate it. It's not just about an occasional insult in a drama. It's about white people expressing their authority by disrespecting and dehumanising non-whites. That is abusive.
It is an abuse of power and an expression of authority.
 
Last edited:

tommie

Telly Talk Hero
Remove Dallas and Dynasty and replace them with an endless loop of the episode where Donna Martin cured the world of racism with her funky moves!

2h5ibmw.gif
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
You don't understand. If a white actor is in blackface and is mocking of someone's race that is abuse! There have been television shows where that has been the case. White people playing black or Asian people in a mocking way. That is abusive and it contributes to a culture of bulling and discrimination. School children see it, and go on to replicate it. It's not just about an occasional insult in a drama. It's about white people expressing their authority by disrespecting and dehumanising none whites. That is abusive.
It is an abuse of power and an expression of authority.

I do understand it’s abuse when broadcast but not when made. The distinction I’m drawing is between these too. I agree that the broadcast is abusive and I would not broadcast it. But I do not want a government to tell anyone what they can’t broadcast. I’m fine with time of day, and medium restrictions, son maybe it’s straight to DVD) but not with a complete ban. Nothing, even abuse, should be completely banned because of the reasons I stated 1) then anything is open to be banned and 2) the abuse only goes into bidding. Though I do see the need to ban child pornography to prevent (as much as possible) the making of it.
 

Michael Torrance

Telly Talk Mega Star
Sorry to add to the off-topic conversation, but I gotta say: I can't wait until some right-wing channel airs Spike Lee's Do the Right Thing with a contextual introduction of how it incites racial violence and can only be shown to its audience with that warning. I will then copy and paste all the comments from the censorship defenders who will be up in arms--together with my "I told you so" banner. Caaaaaaan't wait. :popcorn:
 

Sarah

Moderator Emerita
As the person who started this thread I have to stress that I in no way believe that Dallas should be removed from any streaming’s service!!! :(

I just thought it would be an interesting discussion based on recent events in the world.

Dallas is one of my greatest loves - I’d go postal if anyone made a decision like that.
 

stevew

Telly Talk Star
How is it not abuse when it's made. How is that an ok thing to do? Please explain?

The people making it are not abusing someone in the room as it’s made. They are capable of walking away. They might even agree with it. If this isn’t the case, if a person was drugged or a gun held to their head then yes I’ll agree it was abuse. The child in the making of pornography is not in the same position. In their situation it is abuse even if they say yes they want to do it, because like the drugged (even if they choose to take the drug) person, they are judged not to be of mind to make a decision to participate. Such participation is the abuse that I’m saying must be protected.

Abuse from broadcasting I can see and limiting the time it’s broadcast or restricting it to straight to DVD, but all out censorship no. Again I’m only referring to legal censorship. An individual can censor what ever they want. HBO doesn’t own anyone but it’s owner an explanation for what it pulls.
 
Top